WinInfo Daily News   |   Windows IT Pro
in

SuperSite Blog

Finding a good (and safe) codec package

It's so silly that we have to do this,but as I've been investigating various issues around the Digital Media Core series, I've run into all kinds of compatibility issues with various video formats, especially, so I've been trying to find codec packages that I can recommend to readers without reservation. It's difficult. I've actually paid for a few video codecs over the years, but obviously there are free alternatives, so I'd like to stick to that route if possible. Here are the two that look most interesting to me right now, but that could change over time...

Combined Community Codec Pack. I recommend this on my What I Use page because I really use it and it appears to be pretty complete.

K-Lite Mega Codec Pack. I came across this one recently and just installed on both of my x64-based Vista machines to test. So far so good, but what I've discovered is that there are free and non-free variants, which makes me nervous. Also, where's the "real" home page for this thing?

Does anyone have experience with these or other codecs packages? I'd like something that basically makes H.264, DivX, and Xvid just work with both Windows Media Player and Media Center. It's unclear is this is even possible in a reliable way right now.

Comments

 

rao_v said:

I've been using a codec pack for years, after coming across a film on kazaa i couldnt initially play, back in 2001.I started using the nimo codec pack, which worked like a charm, however due to a realise being unstable and causing various problems (i cant remember the details as its been a while!) i switched to the K-lite codec pack. This codec pack has never, to this day, caused me any problems. Indeed its amoungst the first things i install when i do a clean install of windows and plays everything i through at it.

October 15, 2007 8:24 AM
 

Texnomic said:

I use "Codec Pack All in One" which is great and have all the codecs ever needed even the new wave of .MKV High Defintion content. very recommanded.

October 15, 2007 8:41 AM
 

kenmcnamee said:

I've also been using one of the various K-Lite packs for a couple of years with no issues whatsoever. I use the mega pack on my laptop which does encoding and use the lighter, codec-only version on my machine that's hooked up to my TV.

October 15, 2007 11:00 AM
 

Waethorn said:

As always, you should check to see if any of these codecs are commercial and/or illegal.  K-lite has included copies of commercial MP3 codecs in the past, as well as copies of Real Alternative and Quicktime Alternative, which infringe on software patents and are being sought after by the manufacturers upon which they're based off of.  Also less known is the Indeo codec which is only available commercially by Ligos.  By recommending them here Paul, you're condoning illegal software use.  Would you also condone someone use a product activation crack for a Microsoft product?

"where's the "real" home page for this thing?"

According to many, it's www.free-codecs.com, which advises on how to rip DVD's and share media on P2P networks.

"I'd like something that basically makes H.264, DivX, and Xvid just work with both Windows Media Player and Media Center."

DivX and Xvid should, assuming that you're using a DirectShow codec, and they're in an AVI wrapper.  H.264 is another matter altogether.  DivX's "full"(ish) support of H.264 is relegated to the DivX player.  I've looked for a native H.264 DirectShow codec before, but I've come to the conclusion that one just doesn't exist.  It would seem that every H.264 variant (DivX, QuickTime) are only available with proprietary wrapper codec formats.  The only DirectShow codec for Quicktime is Quicktime Alternative which is a) illegal, and b) doesn't support H.264 properly.

Unfortunately you've come to the same result that I have - if you want to standardize on a video format, check for hardware compatibility before you buy.

October 16, 2007 12:27 AM
 

fgsouza said:

A great coded "package" is the open source software FDDSHOW. It's a collection of DirectShow filters that work great and are much less intrusive than the usual codec packs.

As a reviewer says: "After our reviewers tried FFDSHOW they removed the DivX codecs from their PCs and never looked back. "

And it plays almost every format available and supports playback at Windows Media Player.

www.afterdawn.com/.../ffdshow.cfm

October 22, 2007 5:21 AM

About pthurrott

Paul Thurrott is the guy behind the SuperSite for Windows. Way behind. :)
SPONSORED LINKS FEATURED LINKS

Free Download –VS 2008 TrainingExperts Ken Getz & Robert Green plus labs, code, courseware Maximize speed, performance and reliablity of your PCs and servers—automatically!Speed Up Your PC! Try Diskeeper 2008 with InvisiTasking Free Now! Register for SolarWinds VM MonitorGet X-Ray Vision into Your ESX Servers with SolarWinds FREE VM Monitor GoGrid Offers FREE Trial for Windows Cloud ServersDeploy Windows Server 2003 and 2008 with free load balancing through GoGrid’s award winning web-based GUI – all in less than 5 minutes Order Your SQL Fundamentals CD Today! Learn how to use SQL Server, understand Office integration techniques and dive into the essentials of SQL Express and Visual Basic with this free SQL Fundamentals CD. How healthy is your Exchange Server? Find out Now!Automatic Exchange Server Maintenance helps prevent disasters and improves performance. Download a FREE Exchange Server analysis tool. You've Deployed SharePoint...Now What?This one-day free online conference delivers the technical knowledge needed to kick MOSS up a notch. In one information-packed day, independent SharePoint experts will present practical, real-world information and provide take-away, ready-to-use solutions Ease Your Scripting Pains with the Flexibility of PowerShell!Paul Robichaux equips you with PowerShell basics in 3 introductory lessons, each followed by live Q&A—all on your own computer! Register today! What Would You Do If You Ran Microsoft?ITTV's 2008 inaugural video contest, "If I Ran Microsoft..." is your chance to tell it like it is. Be goofy or be serious, but don"t miss this chance to have fun, win prizes, and go viral in a major way. Maximize Your SharePoint InvestmentThis web seminar discusses how true bi-directional replication of SharePoint content from one server to another enables branch offices to maintain access to current SharePoint content. Rock Your Knowledge, and Compete with Friends and Colleagues!Are you the Web Application Performance Guru in your office? It's time to have fun! Download now to access the crossword puzzle. Challenge yourself and complete this fun activity!
Windows IT Pro |  Subscribe |  Register |  Windows FAQ |  Media Kit |  WinInfo News |  Europe Edition |  About Us |  Contact Us/Customer Service |  Affiliates/Licensing
SQL Server Magazine |  Office & SharePoint Pro |  Windows Dev Pro |  IT Library |  Technical Resources Directory |  Windows Excavator |  ITTV |  IT Job Hound

Copyright © 2008 Penton Media, Inc., All rights reserved.  Terms and Use | Privacy Statement | Reprints and Licensing