WinInfo Daily News   |   Windows IT Pro
in

SuperSite Blog

XP Mode and gaming: Not so much

I've gotten a lot of questions about whether XP Mode will be suitable for gaming.

Put simply, no, it will not be suitable for gaming.

First, this technology is aimed at businesses, not consumers. It's licensed only for Windows 7 Pro, Enterprise, and Ultimate. What Microsoft is trying to accomplish here is to remove the final deployment blockers for its most recent version of Windows. Those are compatibility related. Many businesses run older applications or, more important, custom apps that they built on older Windows versions.

Second, it's based on Virtual PC vNext (7.0) not Hyper-V, and the performance you get is similar to what you see in VPC today. That is, it's fine for applications, not so good for anything strenuous.

As a caveat, I suppose that older, DOS-style games that run on XP (DOOM or whatever) might run fine under this environment, but I haven't tried that yet. And let's face it, you can always use DOSBox or whatever for that stuff.

BTW: Fun XP Mode fact: XP Mode application windows running under Windows 7 cannot take advantage of things like Aero Snap.

Comments

 

Waethorn said:

DOSbox is better for DOS games.  You can route MIDI calls to any Windows-compatible MIDI interface while the program emulates an MPU-401.  That means if you have an MT-32 (I have 2!  :P ) or a good General MIDI tone module laying around (I have a Yamaha MU15XG which does General MIDI, Roland GS, as well as Yamaha XG), you can plug it into your favourite Windows-compatible USB MIDI interface and play games as they were meant to sound.

DOSbox also allows you to put speed governers on games so that when you play Space Quest 1 AGI, Roger Wilco isn't doing Warp 10 when walking down the halls of the Arcada.  (You know what I mean)

....sometimes it's funnier when you leave the speed controls off when playing Leisure Suit Larry though.  :P

April 25, 2009 11:36 AM
 

kenmcnamee said:

I can personally attest that Ages of Empires I and II run perfectly fine in a virtual machine. ;)

April 25, 2009 11:44 AM
 

XP Mode and gaming: Not so much « Windows 7 Help - Tutorials, News, Software & More! said:

Pingback from  XP Mode and gaming: Not so much «  Windows 7 Help - Tutorials, News, Software & More!

April 25, 2009 12:32 PM
 

LuxZg said:

Who cares about games, if they were pre-Vista games you've already played them on XP. And if they were released in last 2 years they are probably compatible with Vista, so in turn compatible with Windows 7. Anything else should be gone if you're a true gamer :)

Anyway, if you game old games a lot, dual boot :P Not that I wouldn't like to see games running in VPC or VXP or XPM whatever it will be called.. but I don't see it as a major problem.

Corporate enviroments don't game anway .. yeah, right ;)

April 25, 2009 1:01 PM
 

anonymuos said:

Age of Empires I and II (and Rise of Rome and Conquerors expansions) work flawlessly NATIVELY on Windows 7, why would anyone then want it to run in the XP Mode Virtual machine?

Btw, Virtual PC sucks at the core, (no 3D support like VMware Workstation 6.5) which already has this feature in the form of "Unity mode". And soon VirtualBox will get this too (Seamless mode). Not locked for XP guests and Windows 7 hosts and locked out for Home Premium users like Microsoft's "XP Mode".

April 25, 2009 1:02 PM
 

Delmont said:

Again, the whining by people who have never worked/supported I.T. in an Enterprise Environment.  This XP Mode is for Enterprise/Corporate to run legacy apps....not GAMES.

Get it?

Geesh!

April 25, 2009 1:24 PM
 

mikegalos@msn.com said:

Delmont

Actiually this really is geared more for the small to medium businesses. The big Enterprise IT groups can do this with MED-V and get the additional management and control that they need, Of course, if they don't need all the stuff in MED-V, this is another option for them.

April 25, 2009 1:32 PM
 

La Web de Programación said:

Windows Mobile 6.5 en mayo : Aunque como comenta la noticia, hasta otoño no veremos teléfonos con él

April 25, 2009 2:49 PM
 

Topics about Microsoft » XP Mode and gaming: Not so much said:

Pingback from  Topics about Microsoft  » XP Mode and gaming: Not so much

April 25, 2009 3:18 PM
 

Waethorn said:

Gametap still doesn't support Windows Vista that well, and NONE of the Windows games play on x64.  That just sucks.  I discontinued my service in 2007 though.

April 25, 2009 4:45 PM
 

XP Mode and gaming: Not so much - SuperSite Blog | GIT Fourm said:

Pingback from  XP Mode and gaming: Not so much - SuperSite Blog | GIT Fourm

April 25, 2009 6:40 PM
 

Victek said:

It's understandable why folks would like games that only run on properly in XP to work in a virtual XP environment, but even if it supported 3D acceleration this would not be optimal.  3D games ALWAYS need to run on bare metal for best performance and, as anyone who plays them knows, you're always wishing they were faster.  If you want to run games in XP dual-booting is the way to go.

April 25, 2009 8:33 PM
 

vgworld.info » XP Mode and gaming: Not so much - SuperSite Blog said:

Pingback from  vgworld.info » XP Mode and gaming: Not so much - SuperSite Blog

April 26, 2009 3:00 AM
 

Windows XP Mode in Windows 7 will not support games | Geekword said:

Pingback from  Windows XP Mode in Windows 7 will not support games | Geekword

April 26, 2009 4:59 AM
 

gorath said:

Victek, which winXP games do you know of that don't work under Vista? I'm not being snarky, I just don't know of any myself.

Any game that works in vista (which as far as I know, is any game that works on XP) should be fine with Win7 anyway.

April 26, 2009 5:32 AM
 

Victek said:

Gorath,

Well, I do very, very little gaming so I can't offer a list.  I do have a copy of Quake 4 though, which pops up a message warning of compatibility problems when trying to install on Vista.  I haven't explored this to see if it can be made to work properly.

April 26, 2009 10:37 AM
 

Windows 7 Blog » Blog Archive » XP Mode and gaming: Not so much said:

Pingback from  Windows 7 Blog  » Blog Archive   » XP Mode and gaming: Not so much

April 26, 2009 6:59 PM
 

Microsoft Tips XP Compatibility Mode in Windows 7 « Tech Share said:

Pingback from  Microsoft Tips XP Compatibility Mode in Windows 7 « Tech Share

May 18, 2009 4:40 AM
 

Law firm specialising in mesothelioma cancer in Delmont, Delmont mesothelioma lawyers said:

Pingback from  Law firm specialising in mesothelioma cancer in Delmont, Delmont mesothelioma lawyers

August 16, 2009 2:08 AM
Acceptable Use Policy

About pthurrott

Paul Thurrott is the guy behind the SuperSite for Windows. Way behind. :)
SPONSORED LINKS FEATURED LINKS

Calculate your savings nowSee how SAN is 57% cheaper than DAS over three years Free CDs Offer Fundamental Content for IT ProsAre you up to speed on the latest technologies and solutions? Don't miss out on your chance to get up to speed quickly on fundamental, in-depth information on some of the hottest topics in our library of content. Let Your Users Reset Their Own Passwords: Free Download Try a 30 day free trial of Desktop Authority Password Self-Service – it provides an easy-to-use, robust system for allowing users to reset their own forgotten passwords or locked accounts. Exchange Server 2010: Deploying Unified Communications - Virtual conferenceDecember 1, 2009 - Free Registration. Build your Unified Communications future on a strong Exchange Server 2010 foundation. Get Windows IT Pro & Mark Minasi’s Favorite Power Tools GuideOrder Windows IT Pro now and get "More of Mark Minasi's Favorite Power Tools"--a in-depth guide to the most useful Windows commands --FREE with your paid order! Subscribe today, and save 58% off the cover price! Migration, Virtualization, Availability, and Desktop ManagementRealize the importance of a workload optimization strategy...it can affect your bottom line! Deep Dive into VMware vSphere, eLearning SeriesJoin John Savill to explore the major functionality capabilities of the vSphere virtualization platform, including identification of the changes from ESX 3.5.
Windows IT Pro |  Subscribe |  Register |  FAQ for Windows |  Media Kit |  WinInfo News |  Europe Edition |  About Us |  Contact Us/Customer Service |  Affiliates/Licensing
SQL Server Magazine |  Office & SharePoint Pro |  WinDevPro |  asp.netPRO |  IT Library |  Technology Resource Directory |  ITTV |  IT Job Hound

© 2009 Penton Media, Inc.     Terms of Use | Privacy Statement | Reprints and Licensing